Every driver has experienced that jolt when you hit a pothole you didn't see coming, the vibration in your steering wheel after driving over rough pavement, or the unexpected expense of replacing a damaged tire.
But where are drivers experiencing the most vehicle repairs associated with challenging road conditions?
For the second year, Pep Boys analyzed service data from its tire and auto service centers across the country to identify the U.S. metro areas with the highest rates of road-related vehicle repairs.
From wheel alignments and suspension repairs to tire damage and wheel balancing, the 2026 Worst Roads in America report reveals where drivers experience above-average repair activity and how challenging driving conditions can affect their vehicles.
This year, Chicago claims the No. 1 spot, while Southern markets account for more than 70% of the top 30 rankings. Approximately 87% of ranked markets are located east of the Mississippi River, highlighting the concentration of repair-heavy markets across the Eastern and Southern United States.
.png)
Key Highlights: America's Worst Roads in 2026
Based on Pep Boys service data from September 14, 2025, through September 13, 2026, 30 metro areas were identified across the U.S. with elevated rates of vehicle repairs commonly associated with challenging road conditions.
Here are the biggest findings:
- Chicago takes the top spot. Chicago moves from No. 2 in 2025 to No. 1 in 2026, replacing Orlando, which falls to No. 16.
- The South dominates the rankings. Southern markets account for 73% of the 2026 list, with 22 of the 30 ranked markets located in the region.
- Gulf Coast states are heavily represented. Florida, Alabama, Louisiana, and Texas collectively account for nearly half (47%) of all ranked markets.
- Florida leads all states. Five Florida markets make the list: Tampa-St. Petersburg-Sarasota, Panama City, Orlando-Daytona Beach-Melbourne, Miami-Fort Lauderdale, and West Palm Beach.
- Eight new markets enter the rankings. Waco-Temple-Bryan, Cleveland, Chattanooga, Shreveport, Birmingham, San Antonio, Memphis, and Huntsville appear on the 2026 list after being absent from the 2025 top 30.
- Eight markets from 2025 fall off the list. Last year's Worst Roads list contained several markets that did not make it into this year's count: Lafayette, IN (ranked 4 last year), Tallahassee, FL (9), Knoxville, TN (10), Springfield, MO (15), Columbus, OH (16), Lafayette, LA (18), San Francisco, CA (29), and El Paso, TX (30).
Chicago Claims the No. 1 Spot
Chicago rises to the top of the 2026 rankings after finishing second in 2025, experiencing above-average rates of single-tire replacements and wheel balancing services. Last year's top-ranked market, Orlando, saw its tire repair and alignment indexes fall below the national benchmark.
Chicago's harsh winters, repeated freeze-thaw cycles, and heavy traffic can create challenging conditions for drivers. When water seeps into pavement cracks and freezes, it expands, contributing to potholes and uneven road surfaces.
Hitting a pothole can damage a tire, bend a wheel, or affect a vehicle's alignment. Drivers who notice new vibrations, steering problems, or tire damage after hitting a pothole should have their vehicles inspected before minor issues become more expensive repairs.
Southern Markets Continue to Dominate
Twenty-two of the 30 ranked metro areas are located in the South, with Nashville, Tampa, New Orleans, Panama City, and Charleston among the highest-ranked markets. Gulf Coast states are particularly prominent, accounting for nearly half of the entire list.
Southern drivers face a different mix of challenges than those in colder climates. Extreme heat, heavy rainfall, flooding, and ongoing construction can contribute to deteriorating pavement and difficult driving conditions.
Nashville makes one of the most notable moves in this year's rankings, climbing from No. 7 to No. 2. The increase is associated with higher suspension repair activity, with Nashville now exceeding the average market in this category.
Repeated impacts from potholes and uneven pavement can put added stress on shocks, struts, and other suspension components, potentially affecting ride comfort, steering, and vehicle stability.
Florida Remains the Most Represented State
Florida once again leads the rankings, with five metro areas accounting for approximately 17% of the top 30.
Tampa-St. Petersburg-Sarasota ranks No. 3, followed by Panama City at No. 5, Orlando-Daytona Beach-Melbourne at No. 16, Miami-Fort Lauderdale at No. 18, and West Palm Beach at No. 29.
Florida's combination of intense heat, heavy rain, coastal weather, and high traffic volumes can contribute to road wear. Road debris and damaged pavement can also increase the risk of tire punctures and other vehicle damage.
Eight New Metro Areas Join the Rankings
Eight markets enter the 2026 top 30 after not appearing on last year's list: Waco-Temple-Bryan, Texas; Cleveland, Ohio; Chattanooga, Tennessee; Shreveport, Louisiana; Birmingham, Alabama; San Antonio, Texas; Memphis, Tennessee; and Huntsville, Alabama.
Their appearance highlights how elevated repair activity isn't limited to the nation's largest metropolitan areas. Drivers in smaller and midsize markets can also experience vehicle wear associated with potholes, rough pavement, and other challenging road conditions.
What Cities Have the Worst Roads in America in 2026?
According to Pep Boys' 2026 analysis of service activity, these 30 metro areas rank highest for vehicle repairs commonly associated with challenging driving conditions:
- Chicago, IL
- Nashville, TN
- Tampa-St. Petersburg-Sarasota, FL
- New Orleans, LA
- Panama City, FL
- Youngstown, OH
- Charleston, SC
- Augusta, GA
- Waco-Temple-Bryan, TX
- Cleveland, OH
- Chattanooga, TN
- Evansville, IN
- Shreveport, LA
- Baton Rouge, LA
- Philadelphia, PA
- Orlando-Daytona Beach-Melbourne, FL
- Mobile-Pensacola, AL-FL
- Miami-Fort Lauderdale, FL
- Dallas-Fort Worth, TX
- Pittsburgh, PA
- Birmingham, AL
- Baltimore, MD
- Norfolk, VA
- Boston, MA
- Charlotte, NC
- Harrisburg, PA
- San Antonio, TX
- Memphis, TN
- West Palm Beach, FL
- Huntsville, AL
These rankings reflect repair patterns in markets served by Pep Boys rather than direct measurements of pavement conditions or government road-quality ratings.
How Potholes and Rough Roads Can Damage Your Vehicle
Potholes, uneven pavement, road debris, and other challenging driving conditions can affect more than just your comfort behind the wheel. Over time, repeated impacts can contribute to tire damage, steering problems, suspension wear, and other costly repairs.
To develop the 2026 rankings, Pep Boys analyzed five categories of vehicle service activity. Here's how each relates to common road hazards, what warning signs drivers should watch for, and how Pep Boys can help.
Wheel Alignments: Why Your Car Pulls to One Side
Hitting potholes, curbs, or uneven pavement can affect your vehicle's wheel alignment, changing the angles at which your tires contact the road.
Signs your vehicle may need a wheel alignment include:
- Your vehicle pulls to the left or right while driving on a level road.
- Your steering wheel is crooked when driving straight.
- Your tires show uneven or premature tread wear.
- Your vehicle doesn't handle as smoothly as it normally does.
Driving with improper wheel alignment can shorten tire life and affect handling. Addressing alignment issues early can help prevent unnecessary tire replacement costs.
If you notice these symptoms, schedule a wheel alignment service at Pep Boys to help restore proper vehicle handling and tire performance.
Suspension Repairs: How Rough Roads Affect Shocks and Struts
Your vehicle's suspension system helps absorb bumps, maintain tire contact with the road, and keep your ride stable.
Repeated impacts from potholes, cracks, and uneven pavement can accelerate wear or damage components such as shocks, struts, control arms, and other suspension parts.
Common signs of suspension problems include:
- Excessive bouncing after driving over bumps.
- Clunking or knocking noises when driving on rough roads.
- A rougher or less comfortable ride.
- Uneven tire wear.
- Difficulty maintaining stable steering or handling.
Ignoring worn suspension components can affect vehicle control and contribute to additional tire wear.
Pep Boys offers steering and suspension services to help identify worn or damaged components and restore proper vehicle performance.
Tire Repairs: What to Do When a Pothole Damages Your Tire
Potholes, sharp road debris, and rough pavement can puncture tire tread, damage sidewalls, or contribute to air leaks.
Sometimes the damage is immediately obvious, such as a flat tire. Other times, drivers may notice a slow loss of tire pressure or a warning from their tire pressure monitoring system (TPMS).
Signs of possible tire damage include:
- A tire that repeatedly loses air pressure.
- Visible cuts, punctures, or bulges in the tire.
- A tire pressure warning light.
- New vibrations after hitting a pothole.
- A flat tire or sudden loss of air pressure.
Depending on the location and severity of the damage, some tread punctures may be safely repairable. Sidewall damage and structural damage typically require tire replacement.
If you suspect damage, visit Pep Boys for flat tire repair services. A technician can inspect the tire and determine whether repair or replacement is the best option.
Single-Tire Replacements: When Tire Damage Can't Be Repaired
A large pothole, sharp object, or hitting a curb can cause damage that makes a tire unsafe to continue using.
While some punctures can be repaired, tires with sidewall damage, structural damage, or punctures outside the repairable tread area typically need to be replaced.
Replacing one damaged tire may be an option, depending on your vehicle's drivetrain, the condition of the remaining tires, and manufacturer recommendations. Some vehicles, particularly those with all-wheel drive, may require additional tire replacement to maintain appropriate tread-depth differences.
Schedule tire services at Pep Boys, where a technician can assess your tires and recommend the appropriate replacement.
Drivers can also explore tire road hazard protection options when purchasing eligible tires at Pep Boys, helping provide added protection against certain unexpected road-related tire damage.
Wheel Balancing: Why Your Steering Wheel Vibrates
If your steering wheel starts vibrating after hitting a pothole, your wheels or tires may have sustained damage or developed an imbalance.
Wheel balancing helps ensure that the weight of a tire and wheel assembly is distributed evenly as it rotates.
Signs your wheels may need balancing include:
- Vibrations in the steering wheel at certain speeds.
- Shaking or vibrations through the vehicle.
- Uneven tire wear.
- Reduced ride comfort, particularly at highway speeds.
Pothole impacts can also bend wheels or damage tires, causing symptoms similar to wheel imbalance. An inspection can help identify the underlying cause.
Pep Boys offers tire installation and wheel balancing services to help drivers maintain a smoother, more comfortable ride.
Pep Boys Is Here to Help Keep You Moving
America's worst roads aren't just frustrating. Potholes, uneven pavement, and road debris can lead to unexpected tire damage, alignment problems, and suspension repairs that affect both your vehicle's performance and your wallet.
"The repairs we see in our service bays reflect the roads our customers drive every day," said Ken Lichty, ASE Master Technician and Technical Trainer at Pep Boys. "Whether it's tire damage or suspension wear, staying ahead of it with regular tire, alignment, and suspension checks can help drivers avoid bigger repair bills down the road."
Pep Boys offers a complete range of tire, repair, and maintenance services designed to help keep vehicles road-ready.
From tire replacements and wheel alignments to steering and suspension repairs, our technicians can help identify road-related damage and recommend the right service for your vehicle.
Notice tire damage, unusual vibrations, or steering problems after hitting a pothole?
Schedule an appointment at Pep Boys to have your vehicle inspected and get back on the road with confidence.
About the 2026 Worst Roads in America Rankings
The 2026 Worst Roads in America report is based on Pep Boys internal service data from September 14, 2025, to September 13, 2026, across U.S. markets where Pep Boys operates. Puerto Rico and closed stores were excluded.
Markets were scored across five service categories: wheel alignment, suspension, tire repair, single-tire replacement, and wheel balancing.
Each category was measured as a percentage of service work order count, except single-tire replacement, which was measured as a percentage of tire service work order count. Markets received one point for each category in which their index exceeded 100 compared with other markets, for a maximum of five points. Service work order count was used as the tiebreaker.
These rankings reflect vehicle service trends at Pep Boys locations and do not directly measure pavement conditions, establish the causes of individual repairs, or represent government road-quality ratings.



